Republican presidential hopeful Rudy Giuliani wants a national ID for all foreigners, what do you think?

"Rudy Giuliani vowed Tuesday to stop the flow of illegal immigrants into the United States by closely tracking visitors to the country and beefing up border security. " Is he on the right track? And what more should be don't to halt the flow of illegals into the US? what more should be done

Public Comments

1. NO, he's not on the right track. That doesn't even make sense! He vowed to stop the flow of illegal immigrants into the US by closely tracking visitors? How about securing our borders and stop the enabling of illegal immigrants already here? Giving them national ID's would only make them more comfortable here.
2. Yeah, that's why New York is a sanctuary city. He full of bs like the rest of them.
3. better take that ID allocated money and repair bridges.....
4. All of you need "illegals" to get food and services cheaper, but dont want rights for them? Not even an ID? What a crazy people!
5. I would like to know more about NY being a sanctuary city, like when it became one. Enforce the immigration laws that we already have.
6. No his idea already is suppose to be law already with regard to the real id act and you see how well that's going delay after delay.
7. Giuliani is treading water and trying to hang on with his fingernails, but his stupid remarks aren't going to get him into the White House. What he did during 9/11 as mayor of NYC is about the same that anybody who was mayor would have done...his job. Outside of 9/11, he doesn't have much experience under his belt to be President. To the poster who believes we need illegals, you are so wrong! Maybe your activist organizations are pouring that into your head while they are using all of you as their slaves to go protest here, march there....see how far it's gotten you? NOWHERE. Can you tell me what THEY have given you being they are on your side? Probably NOTHING, right? The American citizens are tired of paying to support your butts, you don't belong here, go home and fix your own country. No we don't want to give you anything, not an ID card, food, clothing, shelter, health care, education, or JOBS. Even Bush is starting to turn against illegals now, so he doesn't want you here either... say hallelujah America! Here's something we might give you....How about a free flight back to Mexico...your choice: with or without a parachute?
8. I think you got it wrong because it doesn't make sense. I think what he wants is national ID card for all here legally and citizens. The only ones against it are the ones that are for open borders. We already have a SS card we just need one like a credit card with only part of the number visible and none tamper proof. Credit card companies have been doing it for years. The ones that are against it use the stupidest reasoning. Privacy LOL Privacy what a bunch of crap. We give it out to everyone even the paper boy. Who is kidding who here. That would sure solve a lot of the I D thief. that is going on today including illegal immigration. It will eventually happen I just hope before to many more American have there life ruined because of I D thief or killed by an illegal.