Is Rudy Giuliani really electable?

I just read that Rudy Giuliani will be successful in getting the GOP nomination because he is "electable". But I just think he's the wrong guy to go agaist Hilary Clinton. What do you think?

Public Comments

1. cmon...against hillary...RU PAUL would be electable, so why not rudy?
2. More so than anything I've seen on the left and he's not in even on my list of top 4.
3. too liberal for me. I couldn't vote for him
4. He's wrong no matter who he runs against
5. I plan on voting for him and he's buying up most of Texas, so I'd have to say yes.
6. IT does not matter. Our Current president was not elected to be president!!!
7. I am voting for him.
8. I am not looking to pick a winner but vote for the person that best represents my views. Any Republican that wins is going to have the entire parties backing against Hillary. Besides Mcain runs the best against Hillary in a head to head poll. Doesnt this make Him more electable than Rudy? Either way I am voting for Ron Paul. He is the only honest GOP man running in my opinion.
9. If you wish Hilary to be president, then roll Rudy in . Rudy is just like a weather vane, he would never lead .. no convictions. Just a wannabe President .
10. I agree completely. When you match my positions with Giuliani's, that's who I should vote for. We are right on the money with every key indicator except one. He is,without question, the best man for the job. But, I am a New Yorker. I know that Giuliani did not get the Mafia out of NY without making some deals with the Devil. I have some personal experience with how it was done. Now that both Hillary and Bill are in NY politics, (Bill's office is in Harlem) they know where all Rudy's bodies are buried. (metaphor) She will wipe the floor with him in the general election. I'll vote for Romney in the primary and if he doesn't say or do something stupid, I will work on his campaign in the general.
11. that dude is a joke! goohliani is bought and paid for like all the other candidates. with the exception of Ron Paul
12. I think he's more electable than any other Republican this year just because he's much more moderate than most of the other Candidates. But if he doesn't get off his 9/11 soapbox (not that he didn't do an amazing job there, he just needs to focus on other areas) he may lose the nomination just because very few people know exactly where he stands on the issues. But I mean, thats just my opinion, it doesn't make me right, ya know?